Tuesday, 13 April 2010

Pat's Palestine Blog 4

Pat Devlin, who is known to many of us in the region, not least through her work with CAP, is at present in Palestine as part of the World Council of Churches' Ecumenical Accompaniment Programme in Palestine and Israel (EAPPI).

Here she continues her regular blog through sharing what she calls "a news sheet with a difference"..... "I thought some of you might be interested in a Gandhian perspective on the West Bank. It certainly gave me the broader perspective and inspiration, I needed at the time."


Meeting at the friends Boys school Ramallah - 5.4.10

Speakers : Rajmohan Gandhi & Mustafa Barghouti

Silje and Pat were attending a meeting at Ramallah Friends Boys School, hosted by the National Palestinian Initiative, whose general secretary is Mustafa Barghouthi and who have the following 3 aims:

  • End the Occupation
  • Resist
  • End Racism

Mustafa Barghouthi was the first to speak He started by welcoming particularly all the young people who were present at the meeting. He set the tone by saying Gandhi epitomized the fact that moral spirit is greater than material might. He called tortured people to unite in seeking freedom ‘No one can ride on your back unless you bend’

Mahatma Gandhi visited Palestine in 1938. He said then that Palestine should be for the Arabs and that it was a crime against humanity to deprive them of their land. Gandhi developed a model for building popular resistance. Barghouthi advocated a boycott of Israeli products, not just settlement products and further international sanctions against Israel. He said the current present struggle was not a conflict between equals, but a struggle between the oppressed and the oppressor.

Rajmohan Gandhi opened by saluting the Palestinian ability to enjoy life despite hourly humiliation and suffering. He saluted the Palestinian struggle against injustice He then summarized the key points in Mahatma Gandhi’s life, starting with his relationship to South Africa. He said India was a land of diversity, but rigidly divided by caste, whereas in South Africa all castes and religions, which were not Afrikaans, were thrown together

He returned to India with a strategy to unite all groups starting from his home region. He set up a training centre to mobilize people from all backgrounds. His followers took vows: Traditional vows like: truth, non violence, non accumulation of property New vows including: to work for the unity & friendship of all communities

  • To work against Untouchability
  • To live with fearlessness
  • To earn their bread through the sweat of their brow

Using these methods he led a victorious struggle against imperialism. The British had greater respect for a non violent fighter than fear of a violent fighter. In India, Hindus are the majority, Muslims the minority. Extreme Hindus killed Mahatma Gandhi in 1948. But his death advanced his cause. He had a great Muslim friend, a Pashtun leader from Afghanistan called Abdullah Khan. Abdullah opposed the tradition of honour killing. He spent 27yrs in prison under the British and Pakistanis, like the many Palestinians who have spent long years in prison and like Nelson Mandela. He spent his life fighting for democracy and visited Jerusalem in 1920.

Rajmohan then went on to reflect on what he had seen during his brief visit to Palestine. He said the settlements, wall and roads that divide Palestinians from each other and prevent them from earning their livelihoods are more ugly than he realized and he hoped that this knowledge would burn in his heart forever. He said these realities nullify Israeli talk of their desire to see a Palestinian State. Israel is promoting fear among its own people to continue the enforced policy of domination and expansionism. They view the Palestinians as an inferior race not meriting equality and respect. They never talk of colonialism being good for the Palestinians

He again expressed his admiration for the Palestinian’s creativity and struggle and encouraged them that they were winning small victories again and again eg. opening a road, retaining land Preserving an olive tree are all precious victories. He had also been very impressed by the work of Palestinian civil society in: education, medical relief, facilities for the disabled, training women doctors, teaching children to help each other.

“Self confidence will be found with one hand fighting for your rights and the other hand reconstructing civil society” This is not just a coping strategy – it is a sign you are winning victory.”

Then he turned to the international community. Injustice anywhere is injustice everywhere. The independence of India , Pakistan, Sri Lanka are incomplete without the independence of Palestine He saluted the Israelis who support the Palestinian struggle If I don’t join the struggle for this I am a smaller person. We have to meet our maker who will ask us what we did about injustice.

Why does God take so long to give victory to a just cause. It is a mystery like the death of children through natural disaster. I accept mystery. I cannot shake the almighty to act. I must learn patience which is the most frequently used word in the Qu’uran. But we can disturb the sleep of the international community.

On Easter Sunday he was at Abraham’s tomb in Hebron and in Bethlehem, where he prayed for the liberation of Palestine and for his Jewish friends in Israel and the USA. He said he could not offer advice after 3 days but he had some suggestions to offer:

  • Be patient
  • Never lose faith in ultimate victory – the oppressor will crumble under the weight of their own wrong doing
  • Be appreciative of colleagues and don’t blame them for their omissions
  • Continue the work of strengthening civil society – build your Palestinian home – make everything of the highest quality
  • Continue to laugh your way to victory
  • Form a partnership between Muslims & Christians.

A society is great if it respects its minorities He added the international community has duties. Opinion has to be mobilized in support of the Palestinian cause. The sense of justice in Judaism must be aroused. Non violence must always be joined to struggle and resistance. The Palestinian struggle is tougher than the Indian struggle. But the Palestinian people are resilient and gifted. You will find a way to overcome obstacles and move forward

Mustafa Barghouthi responded that Palestinians must develop open thinking capable of learning from others. We must learn not only to be fighters but to be effective: “ We must learn not only to be fighters, but to be effective and achieve results. When we are despondent we count our losses as achievements, but we must measure real achievements”

How can we be effective – Gandhi, Mandela, Martin Luther King started by refusing to accept the injustice. Popular resistance is growing, but we need to unite to be effective. We must be organized and united to succeed. A leadership role is not about position but about what a leader can provide for the people.

“Don’t accept not to be yourselves. Be yourselves and you can be more”

Wednesday, 7 April 2010

Pat's Palestine Blog 3

Is Easter also for Palestinians?

This year, the feast of Pesach (Passover), Palestinian Land Day and Easter for both the Eastern Orthodox and Western Christian Churches all occurred in the same week. Israel announced that the West Bank would be closed (ie people with West Bank I.D.s would have no access to Jerusalem) from Sunday March 28th (Palm Sunday) until April 6th, the Tuesday after Easter.

Palestinian Christians being prevented from attending the traditional Palm Sunday procession organised an alternative procession, starting from Bethlehem and heading for Jerusalem Echoing Jesus’ ride through into Jerusalem crowds of people waving palm branches accompanied riders on a pony and two donkeys through a checkpoint between Bethlehem and Jerusalem on Sunday, the Christian festival of Palm Sunday.

The march was supposed to have stopped at the checkpoint, but once the group reached the checkpoint gate for vehicles, approximately 100 protesters made their way through the gate. Apparently the security guards were unprepared: they were far too few to be able to stop the demonstrators who managed to walk through the second gate and on to the road to downtown Jerusalem, still being led by the donkey and the horse.

About a hundred metres down the road, the Israeli police realised what had happened and blocked the way. The demonstrators stopped, although they easily could have marched on as there were only a few police officers on the scene. In response, the checkpoint was closed for all vehicles and foot traffic attempting to enter Jerusalem. Eleven Palestinians were detained, including a prominent Palestinian politician
Checkpoint 300 - the main Bethlehem checkpoint giving access to Jerusalem from the Southern part of the West Bank- remained completely closed for the rest of the week Those with humanitarian concerns (eg access to hospitals) had to seek access via an alternate checkpoint and access for those wishing to enter Jerusalem for the Holy Week ceremonies at the church of the Holy Sepluchre was very uncertain - eventually some permits for worship were negotiated, but there is now a movement from the churches to resist the demand for such permits





Meanwhile we observed Holy Week about 45 miles north of Jerusalem in the Nablus area. On the Tuesday of Holy Week which was also Palestinian Land Day we went to Awarta, where we took part in a very different kind of procession. On Sunday March 21st, two young men were killed as they worked in the fields below the Izahar settlement. The circumstances of the killing were unclear Men lined the village streets as we arrived and entered the ‘town hall’ for a more official welcome from the mayor and his officers. We were joined by a small group of women which included women from the ambulance service which attended the incident.


At 10 45am we set out to walk to the place where the young men were killed, a distance of about 3 km. It was a solemn march with many carrying pictures of the two young men. When we arrived at the spot people were anxious to tell us their version of events and wanted us to take many pictures.


Then the olive tree planting began both to commemorate the young men and to mark Palestinian Land Day. Some of the youths became high spirited and raced up the hill with the Palestinian flag. The older men watched anxiously in case armed settlers would appear at the fence on the brow of the hill. But, the young men succeeded in planting the flag high on the hill, reclaiming their land in a symbolic way.


The walk back was more relaxed. We shared food and drink and the young men were very keen to talk to us. Many of them had gone to school with Salah and Muhammad and you could see them wrestling with the mixed emotions of anger and grief.













On Good Friday Sonti and I visited a remote village called Khirbet Tana, now in an Israeli military area The dwellings in this village have been demolished 3 times, because the aim is to make it exclusively an Israeli area, part military, part green belt. The villagers are currently living in tents in the midst of their ruined dwellings and dreading the heat of summer

We have been asked to visit because they are about to rebuild the school and there is anxiety that it will be destroyed again before it is completed. As we made our photographic record, the image of the phoenix bird rising from its own ashes came to mind and we carried these images to the Stations of the Cross in Nablus

Easter Saturday here is known as Holy Fire Saturday and there is a tradition that the Holy Fire is taken from the tomb in the Holy Sepulchre Church in Jerusalem and carried out to the cities and villages of Palestine.

We joined the celebrations in the Rafidia area of Nablus. The Holy Fire was brought first to the Church of Jacob’s Well ( where Jesus met the Samaritan Woman) and the Orthodox priest then brought it to Rafidia , where processed between 4 churches, led by the scouts with their drums and flags and flaming torches. We prayed in turn in the Melkite Church, the Anglican Church, the Latin patriarchate Church and finally the new Orthodox church, where everyone was invited to light their candle from the fire.

After this we attended a more traditional Easter Vigil Service in the Anglican church

On Easter Sunday morning I walked to the tomb of Nun, father of Joshua, which is little more than a mile away from our house and offers wonderful views of the Jordan Valley and I tried to allow something of the spirit of Easter to permeate my heart and mind, now so full of often contradictory images.

Pat's Palestine Blog 2

Daily life and Daily Tragedy in Yanoun

In some ways it was a relief to head north to visit the village of Yanoun, where I will be spending my 3 months together with my Norwegian, Swedish and South African team mates. Yanoun is in a very beautiful location, nestling among limestone hills reminiscent of the Peak District. Sheep are the main business of the village and we met the mayor of the village, as he grazed his sheep between the olive trees in the valley below the International House, where we will stay. Taking in the scene around us we picked out the animal sheds, which belong to the Israeli Settlers who live on the hill tops surrounding the village and who are the reason for our presence.



Left - Our team in front of the International House (Sonti, Silje, Pat, Tor) in Upper Yanoun

Right - The new team being shown the ropes: Walking to Lower Yanoun

We cannot see the houses of the settlers, but the village is surrounded on 3 sides by the illegal outpost buildings of the Itamar settlement, some of the settler animal sheds are only 400 metres from the houses of Upper Yanoun. In 2002, the harassment of villagers by settlers became so severe – village men being beaten in front of their children, animals mutilated, crops destroyed – that all the villagers left for Aqraba, the nearest larger village under full Palestinian control. Israeli and international-l peace groups came to the Yanoun to provide a protective presence and slowly, the villagers came back, about 80 in number. The Ecumenical Accompaniment Programme has had a permanent presence in the village since June 2003. In recent years the village has been relatively quiet, but the relentless incremental acquisition of the village land by the settlers continues.

We have now been back in Yanoun for almost a week and are getting used to the rhythm of village life. Life here begins between 4-5am By 7am the shepherds are out with the sheep on the lower slopes of the hills ( all that is now left to them for pasture) and the women have started bread making in the tabouns (the small outbuildings which house a sunken cooking fire) We try to take a walk between 7-8 am just to see that all is well and observe any changes on the hilltops – we may call in to one of the houses to buy fresh food for breakfast.



Left - Cheesemaking

Right - Rashid, Mayor of Yanoun

The women milk the sheep twice a day and make cheese, and yoghurt. They also keep hens for the eggs and the children have rabbits for the pot. The sheeps milk is a real treat on cereal, much better than our shop semi skimmed variety! The village has about 400 acres planted with olive trees and 100 acres planted with almonds figs vines etc. There seems to be a small amount of wheat and vegetables and herbs are often planted between the olive trees. So it could really be the good life, if the villagers were not prevented from tending their olive trees nearest the settlement outposts and only allowed one day to harvest with military protection, instead of 8-10 days. Moreover Israel no longer allows them to export their produce beyond the West Bank

The younger children start school in the village at 8am and the school bus collects the older

ones to take them to school in Aqraba about 3 miles away. Aqraba has a population of about 10,000 and has shops for all our basic needs. The road to Aqraba is the only way out of Yanoun as the direct road to Nablus and it’s surrounding villages has been closed by the Israeli military. This means that very circuitous routes have to be taken to nearby villages, but more of that next time. Meanwhile I’ll let the children of Yanoun have the last word....

Saturday, 3 April 2010

Pat's Palestine Blog 1

Pat Devlin, who is known to many of us in the region, not least through her work with CAP, is at present in Palestine as part of the World Council of Churches' Ecumenical Accompaniment Programme in Palestine and Israel (EAPPI).

It has taken Pat a while to get a laptop and email connection, but we hope now to have regular updates following this first post that tells of her arrival in Jerusalem.

We arrived in a very tense Jerusalem on the evening of March16th. You may have read about the disturbances at Al Aqsa mosque, but what you probably didn’t hear is that Jerusalem had been closed for five days This means that Palestinians who live in the West Bank with permits to work or study or access health care in Jerusalem had not been allowed to enter and no Palestinian was allowed into the Old City of Jerusalem, unless they lived there.

The steps down to the Damascus Gate, which had been teeming with street traders on my previous visit were deserted. Instead, police and military vans lined the northern wall of the Old City and we saw the riot gear being assembled, which some of us have seen on London demonstrations – but here it also includes live amunition . Our Jerusalem training included a session with a coordinator of Breaking the Silence, an organisation for former Israeli soldiers who have decided to speak out about their experience of ‘national service’ He explained that ‘riot’ control procedure is as follows( but sometimes soldiers do not have full range of equipment and stages get missed):

· Order to disperse

· Throw stun grenades & tear gas

· Fire rubber bullets (but the rubber conceals metal bullets & is sometimes removed)

· Fire live ammunition ( officially at the legs)




The picture shows Palestinian men at Friday prayer( behind the military) on the pavement opposite the Damascus Gate, because their entry to the Old City and the Al Aqsa mosque is barred

The closure had originally been declared because of the rebuilding of a Synagogue which had been used as a military launch pad in the defeat of the Arabs in 1948 and this was followed by rumours that the cornerstone of the Third Temple was to be laid at Al Aqsa mosque. The disturbances at the mosque soon spread to areas of East Jerusalem, where Palestinian homes are under threat of demolition, as the Israelis take steps to make Jerusalem their undivided capital.

During our training we took a tour with ICAD ( Israeli Committee Against House Demolitions)




The Picture shows the Al Bustan

Residents’ campaign tent





In the Silwan and Al Bustan neighbourhoods, ( as shown on the Panorama programme) the proposal from the Israeli government is to demolish 88 Palestinian homes, making 1500 people homeless, to make way for the creation of an Archeological Park, part of the excavations for the City of David. This will be a major tourist attraction, but there are serious questions about the archeological authenticity of the excavation. In another area we heard that foreign capital from dubious sources is purchasing all available land between Palestinian settlements in East Jerusalem as part of the Judaisation of Jerusalem and we witnessed the stark contrast in the levels of service (eg. sewage, waste collection, pavements, play facilities) between the new Israeli houses and the existing Palestinian houses although all are paying rates


Sunday, 14 February 2010

Doing anything interesting for Lent?

It’s that time of the year again. Lent. The annual preparation for the commemoration of Holy Week and Easter beyond. Sackcloth and ashes - self-denial, fasting, abstinence! Bring it on!
The Old English word ‘Lent' simply means ‘springtime'. In our church lectionary we turn from the Christmas liturgical cycle to the Paschal cycle, we turn from winter and anticipate summer. In our Lenten services we begin to address Luke’s moving and compassionate parables, his attention to the events of Holy Week and the physician’s beautiful crafted cameo stories of post resurrection experiences.

In an “affluenza” age of unbridled self interest where dominant market forces seem to be that of acquiring, consuming and maintaining “sustained economic growth” the church of late has found ways of softening our Lenten observances. We tell ourselves that Lent isn't about giving things up. We journey to a countryside retreat with a Lakeland Plastics outlet on hand. We may wish to resume membership of a relaxing gym with a bubbling jacuzzi later to detox with juice-broth for inner healing. Perhaps this year a new book may guide us on our spiritual journey (try Timothy Keller’s The Prodigal God). We might engage in positive and creative Lenten activities to express our support with our brothers and sisters who are hungry and thirsty. But fasting and abstinence – a temporary restraint from sex, food and alcohol? Well perhaps not this Lent!

Yet Jesus clearly expects us to fast. He fasted for 40 days, so did Elijah and Moses. A fast is simply a personal act of devotion to God. Jesus told us that when we fast (not if) we are not to make a show of it, like hypocrites do. A fast is different from a hunger strike; it is also different from anorexia nervosa: it is disciplined diet, not total abstention from food. You still eat; you just abstain from certain foodstuffs, by eliminating luxury items from your diet, such as meats and chocolates. The idea of a fast is to draw us closer to God, to love him more. Abs(stin)ence makes the heart grow fonder?

Can we be counter-cultural and get back to old fashioned Lenten observances to think carefully about what fasting and abstinence could mean in our individual spiritual life? For some fasting might imply thinking about reasonable limits on what we can and can't have, for others it might mean a more balanced approach to our lifestyle, maybe to enjoy a more greener lifestyle. Yet others it may mean a new or different approach to focused prayer. Why not try a corporate fast, a day time fast, a fruit and veg fast, a partial fast, a Wesley fast (John Wesley used to fast on Tuesday and Friday most weeks, but would only miss breakfast & lunch)

So go on, turn the telly off, take a phone break and try a disciplined fast this Lent – you may not wish to go up a mountain to pray all night – so instead rest, relax, enjoy a smoothie , read the bible in preparation for Easter – pray - you know it makes spiritual and ecological sense.

Ray Anglesea

Please Note:
1. If you are pregnant, on medication or have any long term illness, please do not undertake
any kind of food or drink fast without the agreement of your doctor.
2. If you use any of the fasts which abstain from food for more than a couple of days, it could
impair your ability to drive or operate machinery.
3. If you experience dizziness or any other unexpected symptoms please stop the fast until you have been able to consult a doctor.

Wednesday, 27 January 2010

Church or Mission? Apply or Die?

What do you think would have happened if the Early Christians had been more focused on Church than on Mission? They would probably, for the first generation have made a reasonable job at it: Jesus would still have been their inspiration and role model and they would have tried to be a very loving community and in that sense would have been quite attractive. But as the generations passed they would have marginalised the Holy Spirit more and more and become more and more locked into tradition and ritual. In the end they would become a kind of Christianised version of the Pharisees intent on keeping themselves pure and locking others out by ever increasing rules.

The truth is that the Early Christians were more focused on Mission than Church; in fact we would think they were zealots for Mission in comparison today. Focused on Mission they won more and more, day after day, to Christ and their numbers grow exponentially, and then whoops we need to organise this lot: oh yes Jesus said about building His Church, so that’s what we will call it and in case folk haven’t got the point another name will be the Body of Christ. That’s thank God how it all started and if it hadn’t then I am not sure we would be sitting here today. Sadly over the years the Christian pendulum has swung between Mission and Church. Up to AD 300 it was Mission that predominated and from 300 AD to the Reformation it was Church and the name History ascribes to that period is the Dark Ages. Thankfully Mission began to reassert itself from the Reformation but it took till Wesley & Whitfield to swung the pendulum back to Mission. Since then Pendulum has largely been more towards Church with a few wonderful individual and corporate exceptions. Focus on Church creates a religious elite or dependency and squeezes out the Missionary zeal and endeavour, which is the life flow of the Holy Spirit, formed Missionary Church.

In Northern Synod, within the URC, and over much of the Body of Christ in the UK we have stark choice to make. We can continue to allow the pendulum to dictate our preoccupation with Church and not with Mission or we can begin to turn the Titanic and decide as congregations what our core business really is and start through some small steps to turn our hearts towards Mission once again.

I believe that when congregations do this the Lord lets out a loud hallelujah and sends His Holy Spirit of Mission to assist as well as an army of angels to protect us as we go out.

Here in Northern Synod we want to encourage churches in this decision: that’s why the Mission 4 Life Fund was established: not so we could feel go we had paid lip service to Mission but so we could engage in Mission once more and become missionary congregations within a Missionary Synod!! And so to our challenge to every congregation.

Before the end of June decide on at least one new initiative in Mission and to go for it. And if you need help financially to fund such a Mission project then please apply for help. We want to hear from every congregation what your initiative is and whether you need help from the fund. If we get more than we have resources to fund we will find the resources from somewhere (perhaps our bigger congregations) but what we are asking of you all is a seed change in thinking, a new step of faith, a leadership decision to become Missionary congregations once again.


The alternative you know as well as I do: this is God’s time and God’s Call to the Synod and its congregations: we ignore it at our peril. Apply or die?


David Bedford

Wednesday, 20 January 2010

Greatest living preacher?

My friend and colleague Ray Anglesea sent me two fascinating links to the Times Online yesterday – both about preaching.

The first, http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/faith/article6993099.ece , outlined some recent research undertaken here in Durham to mark the 50th anniversary of the College of Preachers. This has discovered that people who regularly go to church actually value sermons: 96.6% even claiming to look forward to that point in the service.

Then comes the predictable discussion about how long the sermon should be. We all know that Catholics don’t really preach sermons, but only homilies – and 10 minutes for a homily seems fair enough to me. I don’t know any Baptists myself who’d like their minister to go on for an hour and a quarter – but maybe there are some lurking somewhere. Happily no one seems to have asked for a URC view on the matter – though I suspect we’d be with the fence-sitting Anglicans who’d rather it was all over and done with in ten minutes if it’s boring, but will cope with twenty if there’s something worth engaging with.

Funny though that the researchers seem to feel the need to apologise for the “counter-intuitive” discovery that there might still be something to be said for preaching. And what a strange thing, to suggest that communicating face to face with people pastorally or through preaching somehow puts us into an old-fashioned analogue age, and separates us off from our trendy digital colleagues who use alternative technology and spend half their lives on Facebook. I’ve got a feeling some of us are a bit more versatile than we’re given credit for.

But I liked the quote at the end of the piece that informed us that Rowan Williams was among the church leaders who have signed the College of Preachers’ jubilee pledge, commiting themselves to “forward-looking preaching, engaging faithfully with the Bible, directly with the congregation and prophetically with the world, to proclaim Jesus as Lord”. Surely there’s got to be a whole variety of ways of doing that – and sermons of every length and style to fit the bill!

But then I was a bit surprised by the second link that Ray gave me - http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/faith/article6993077.ece . Times online seems to have been very religious yesterday! Here we have a little run-through of great preachers of the past (Luther, Donne, Wesley etc) to lead to the rather cloying conclusion that “Our greatest living preacher is the Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams. His set speeches are notoriously perplexing but his sermons are something else.” I confess I’ve never heard the Archbishop preach, but I can’t help wondering how on earth you could make the claim that anyone was the greatest preacher around. I know there are Preacher of the Year awards, but I always think they sound like something out of Father Ted.

Surely the problem is there in the first linked piece: different individuals and different Christian traditions have very different ideas of what a sermon is – let alone what constitutes a good sermon. I wonder, are those of us who try to vary our sermon style and content depending on the congregation reckoned to be preaching a better sermon to the one rather than the other? I suspect that across the churches we might find a good deal of agrement on what constitutes a bad sermon (with sheer boredom being a significant factor) but very different ideas on what makes a good sermon or a great preacher.

I’m not sure I’ve got a clue who the greatest living preacher might be. But even if I did, since I don’t think preaching is a competitive activity, I’d rather keep quiet about it.


PS As well as sending round useful links, Ray has recently shared some thoughts with some of his colleagues as he’s been preparing his own sermons. I think several of us last Sunday were sharing thoughts about “the third day” as recorded at Cana in Galilee. Do you know why so many Jews marry on a Tuesday?

I’m wondering if we should develop a synod sermon blog, to share both thoughts and finished sermons. Let me know what you think please!